Skip to content
  • Home
  • Services
    • Audit & Attest
      • Financial Statement Audits
      • Employee Benefit Plans
      • Attestation Engagements
      • Compilations & Review
      • SOC
      • Agreed-Upon Procedures
    • Advisory
      • Transaction Advisory Services
      • Cybersecurity, Technology Risk, Privacy
      • High Net Worth Services
      • Forensic Services
      • Litigation Services
      • Management Consulting
      • Technology Services
      • Valuation Services
    • Business & Tax
      • Corporate Income Tax
      • Individual Income Tax
      • International Tax
      • State and Local Tax Compliance and Tax Minimization Services
      • Tax Planning
    • T&C Family Office Group
  • Industries
    • Construction & Real Estate
    • Healthcare
    • Manufacturing & Distribution
    • Nonprofit Organizations
    • Private Equity Firms
    • Privately-held Companies
    • Technology & Energy
  • Firm
    • Overview
    • Our People
    • Our Community
    • Templeton Group
      • PracticePro 365
      • T&C Family Office Group
      • Templeton Investigative Services
  • Careers
    • Experienced
    • Students
    • Benefits
  • News
  • Pay My Bill
  • Home
  • Services
    • Audit & Attest
      • Financial Statement Audits
      • Employee Benefit Plans
      • Attestation Engagements
      • Compilations & Review
      • SOC
      • Agreed-Upon Procedures
    • Advisory
      • Transaction Advisory Services
      • Cybersecurity, Technology Risk, Privacy
      • High Net Worth Services
      • Forensic Services
      • Litigation Services
      • Management Consulting
      • Technology Services
      • Valuation Services
    • Business & Tax
      • Corporate Income Tax
      • Individual Income Tax
      • International Tax
      • State and Local Tax Compliance and Tax Minimization Services
      • Tax Planning
    • T&C Family Office Group
  • Industries
    • Construction & Real Estate
    • Healthcare
    • Manufacturing & Distribution
    • Nonprofit Organizations
    • Private Equity Firms
    • Privately-held Companies
    • Technology & Energy
  • Firm
    • Overview
    • Our People
    • Our Community
    • Templeton Group
      • PracticePro 365
      • T&C Family Office Group
      • Templeton Investigative Services
  • Careers
    • Experienced
    • Students
    • Benefits
  • News
  • Pay My Bill
CONTACT US

Supreme Court: COLI proceeds are included in business value

  • Blog, Valuation Services

A recent U.S. Supreme Court ruling resolves a circuit split on a business valuation issue — and it could have a major impact on the value of many closely held companies going forward. In Connelly v. IRS (144 S. Ct. 1406, 2024), the Court held that corporate-owned life insurance (COLI) designed to fund the redemption of a deceased shareholder’s stock under a buy-sell agreement should be considered a corporate asset when calculating the value of the decedent’s shares for purposes of the federal estate tax. Here’s a summary of the case and how it may affect owners of other private companies.

IRS challenges estate’s valuation

Two brothers co-owned a building supply company. They entered into a buy-sell agreement to ensure that the business remained in the family if either brother died. Under the agreement, the surviving brother would have the option to purchase the deceased owner’s shares. If the survivor refused, the corporation would be required to redeem the interest at fair market value based on an outside appraisal. The company bought life insurance policies to fund the redemption obligation.

The brother who owned 77.18% of the company’s outstanding shares died in 2013. The surviving brother decided not to purchase the decedent’s shares, triggering a corporate redemption. The company paid the estate $3 million for the interest.

The IRS audited the federal estate tax return and claimed that the fair market value of the decedent’s shares should be $5.3 million. The IRS determined that the $3 million of COLI proceeds used to redeem the decedent’s interest should be included in the value of the entire business, increasing the value of the decedent’s shares by approximately $2.3 million ($3 million × 77.18%). As a result, the estate incurred an additional estate tax obligation of nearly $900,000.

Taxpayer files suit

The estate filed a lawsuit requesting a refund of the additional estate tax assessment. During the audit, the estate hired an accounting firm to determine the value of the decedent’s shares. The valuator determined that the corporation was worth approximately $3.86 million, and the decedent’s interest was worth roughly $3 million ($3.86 million × 77.18%).

When valuing the business, the estate’s expert excluded the COLI proceeds used to redeem the shares, based on the finding in Estate of Blount v. Commissioner (428 F. 3d 1338, CA11 2005). In this case, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 11th Circuit affirmed that insurance proceeds should be deducted from the value of a corporation when they’re “offset by an obligation to pay those proceeds to the estate in a stock buyout.”

The IRS challenged that reasoning in Connelly. The district court sided with the IRS, and the U.S. Court of Appeals for the 8th Circuit affirmed that ruling. The Supreme Court agreed to settle the conflicting circuit court decisions. After reviewing the case facts, the Court unanimously upheld the ruling in Connelly, explaining that “a share redemption at fair market value does not affect any shareholder’s economic interest.” Instead, the Court held that a hypothetical buyer would “treat the life-insurance proceeds that would be used to redeem [the decedent’s] shares as a net asset” without an offsetting liability for the redemption obligation.

Key takeaways

The Supreme Court’s opinion notes that the Connelly decision could make succession planning more complicated for closely held businesses. And it suggests cross-purchase agreements between the shareholders (which bypass the corporation) as a possible workaround for this issue.

The opinion also explains that the Court didn’t rule that a redemption obligation can never decrease a company’s value. For example, a redemption obligation that requires a company to liquidate its assets to fund a buyout would reduce the company’s future earnings capacity. However, the Court did reject the notion that all redemption obligations reduce a corporation’s value.

No universal approach

When valuing a business, case facts matter. If you’re concerned about how COLI would be handled in a particular situation, contact us. Our business valuation professionals can help you determine the appropriate treatment for COLI proceeds and evaluate creative options to minimize federal estate and gift taxes.

© 2024

Categories
  • Agribusiness
  • Assurance, Advisory & Review
  • Audit & Attest
  • Blog
  • Business and Tax
  • Business Consulting & Corporate Compliance
  • Corporate Income Tax
  • Current Opportunities
  • Cybersecurity, Technology Risk, Privacy
  • Employee Benefit Plan
  • Employee Benefit Plans / 401(k)
  • Healthcare
  • High Net Worth Individuals
  • High Net Worth Services
  • Individual Income Tax
  • Industries
  • Manufacturing & Distribution
  • Newsletter Articles
  • Newsletters
  • Nonprofit
  • Press Releases
  • Privately Held Companies
  • Professional Services
  • Real Estate & Construction
  • Retail
  • Services
  • Specialty Tax Services
  • State and Local Tax Complianc
  • T&C Family Office Group
  • Tax Planning
  • Tax Planning & Compliance
  • Technology
  • Uncategorized
  • Valuation Services
  • Valuation Services

SHARE THIS ON:

RELATED POSTS

Employers must stay on top of 401(k) eligibility rules

Employers of all types and sizes continue to sponsor 401(k) plans to attract job candidates and help employees save for retirement. Sure, there are other

Read More »

From the simple to the complex: 6 strategies to protect your wealth from lawsuits and creditors

Asset protection is a strategic approach to safeguarding your wealth from potential lawsuits and creditor claims. Indeed, protecting your assets is critical in today’s litigious

Read More »

Your nonprofit has lost an executive. Now what?

A fictional nonprofit lost its executive director (ED) when she died unexpectedly. The charity had a basic contingency plan, but the document didn’t name an

Read More »

Contact Us

WEST PALM BEACH
Esperante Building
222 Lakeview Avenue
Suite 1200
West Palm Beach, FL 33401
(561) 798-9988
Fax: (561) 798-4053

FORT LAUDERDALE
The Main
201 East Las Olas Boulevard
Suite 1650
Fort Lauderdale, FL 33301
(954) 333-0001
Fax: (954) 765-0719

Twitter Facebook Instagram Youtube Linkedin
© 2025 Templeton & Company. All Rights Reserved. Website by Weber & Co.
Services
  • Audit & Attest
  • Advisory
  • Business & Tax
  • T&C Family Office Group
  • Pay My Bill
  • Audit & Attest
  • Advisory
  • Business & Tax
  • T&C Family Office Group
  • Pay My Bill
Industries
  • Construction & Real Estate
  • Healthcare
  • Manufacturing & Distribution
  • Nonprofit Organizations
  • Private Equity Firms
  • Privately-held Companies
  • Technology & Energy
  • Construction & Real Estate
  • Healthcare
  • Manufacturing & Distribution
  • Nonprofit Organizations
  • Private Equity Firms
  • Privately-held Companies
  • Technology & Energy
Firm
  • Overview
  • Our People
  • Our Community
  • Templeton Group
  • Terms & Conditions
  • Overview
  • Our People
  • Our Community
  • Templeton Group
  • Terms & Conditions
Careers
  • Experienced
  • Students
  • Benefits
  • Experienced
  • Students
  • Benefits